How Payment Choice Is Reshaping the Online Checkout Experience

Why the Way Consumers Pay Now Matters More Than Who They Are

For years, online commerce was framed as a generational shift. Younger shoppers were seen as digital natives, while older consumers were expected to lag behind. New data shows that assumption no longer holds.

Research from PYMNTS Intelligence reveals that eCommerce is now a shared behavior across generations. Consumers from baby boomers through Gen Z shop online at similar rates. The real distinction lies not in adoption, but in how consumers choose to pay once they reach the checkout.

Based on a November 2024 survey of 2,722 U.S. consumers, the January 2025 study shows that payment preferences are shaped by perceptions of security, spending control, and financial comfort rather than age alone.

‍

Payment Behaviour Shifts With the Shopping Channel

In physical retail environments, debit cards remain the preferred option. Forty-two percent of shoppers used debit for their most recent in-store retail purchase, compared with 28 percent who used credit. Paying directly from a bank account continues to appeal to consumers who prioritize visibility and control over spending.

Online, the pattern reverses. Credit cards lead eCommerce transactions, with 38 percent of consumers using credit for their most recent online retail purchase, compared with 30 percent using debit. Consumers appear to view credit as a protective layer in digital environments, offering reassurance when transactions move beyond the physical point of sale.

Digital wallets further highlight this channel-specific behaviour. While only 8 percent of shoppers used a wallet in-store, that figure rose to 16 percent online, suggesting that convenience and privacy play a larger role in virtual checkouts.

‍

Trust, Control, and Retail Context

Where consumers shop also influences how they pay. Debit usage is more common among shoppers frequenting value-driven retailers, reinforcing a focus on budgeting and immediate fund visibility. Credit usage, by contrast, aligns with eCommerce platforms known for scale, convenience, and strong fraud protections.

Amazon continues to dominate online retail behaviour. More than half of consumers using credit for their most recent eCommerce purchase did so on Amazon, with debit users following closely behind.

Walmart maintains its strength in physical retail, capturing nearly one-quarter of debit-based in-store purchases. While its online presence continues to expand, payment behaviour shows its core remains rooted in brick-and-mortar shopping.

‍

A Market That Has Settled Into Routine

One of the most notable findings is the stabilization of eCommerce itself. After years of rapid growth, online retail transactions held steady at 26 percent year over year. Rather than expanding into new demographics, digital shopping has become a normalized part of daily life.

Some generational distinctions persist at the margins. Gen Z and millennials are significantly more likely to make restaurant and grocery purchases online compared with older consumers. These everyday categories represent the next phase of digital comfort, rather than large retail or travel purchases.

As PYMNTS Intelligence notes, the shift to digital commerce may be complete, but the evolution of payment behaviour is ongoing. Debit, credit, and digital wallets now reflect deeper consumer instincts around safety, savings, and financial self-management.

‍

Payment Solutions with Kubera Payments

At Kubera Payments, we help businesses across North America move millions of dollars daily, whether in-store, online, or on mobile.

Our team works closely with merchants and technology partners to align payment strategies with how consumers actually choose to pay. As checkout behaviour becomes more nuanced, flexibility, security, and reliability are essential.

Get expert guidance on optimizing your payment acceptance. Contact our team at sales@kuberapayments.com or 604-484-9278

‍